Bug #22832

[Polish] The localized voice-overs from vanilla BG1 should not be incomplete

Added by Piotr "Cahir" Wiankowski over 3 years ago. Updated over 3 years ago.

Status:Closed - FixedStart date:04/17/2016
Classification:C - MinorDue date:
Assignee:-% Done:

100%

Category:-
Target version:Public Bug Reports - 2.2.66.0
Found In Version:Public Bug Reports - 2.0.62.2

Description

Internal report: #22963

  1. Go to Options -> Sound, set the voice volume to 100%
  2. Go to Options -> Language, select Polski/Polish, click Done, quit and restart the game
  3. Start a new BG:EE game
  4. Ctrl+J to Gorion at [2600.1700]
  5. Talk to Gorion, choose reponse ( 1 ) to leave Candlekeep
  6. Listen to the voice-over in the following cutscene

Observed
Gorion switches to English during the talk at the gate.

Expected
All vanilla BG1 voice-overs should be in Polish.

Notes
There are hundreds of Polish sounds missing from the game. See the attached files. Note that these are in OGG format and need to be converted to the BG:EE standard.

The attachment contains 650 sound files. They should all be added to the Polish BIFs. Most of the files are simply missing. A few others will replace existing files in the BIFs, because the existing files are either in English or invalid for other reasons. Here are some notes for reference:

# Category Examples
1 Files that are missing from the Polish BIFs. These include almost all "hurt" and "dying" voice-overs, voiced sounds like laughter or snoring, and a few other recordings like the error messages. ALDET08, ALDET09
DYNAH38, DYNAH39
ERROR01, ERROR10
MAINM11
2 Files that exist in the Polish BIFs, but are either mute/broken or in English. That includes the Gorion snippets. GANDL01, GANDL02
GORIN10A, GORIN10B
KAGAN04
3 Files that are missing from the Polish BIFs, but they are mute in Polish. These files should be included anyway to restore the Polish BG1 behavior and prevent any English voices from being heard. HUSAM10, HUSAM11, HUSAM12, HUSAM13
SAREV14
TAZOK11
VILFA05, VILFA06
4 Polish sounds that do not have an English counterpart. These recordings exist in Polish, but there does not seem to be a corresponding English file. IMOEN29
SKIEE01A
TWOMN05, TWOMN06
5 Voice-overs for the tutorial from BG2. These files exist in the Polish BIFs but are in English. I assume the provided Polish files were taken from Polish vanilla BG2. TTBELT*, TTBRAN*, TTIMOE*, TTMINS*, TTSER1*, TTXAN*

Polish_missing_sounds.part1.rar (4 MB) Filip Flechtner, 04/21/2016 07:22 PM

Polish_missing_sounds.part2.rar (4 MB) Filip Flechtner, 04/21/2016 07:23 PM

Polish_missing_sounds.part3.rar (2.85 MB) Filip Flechtner, 04/21/2016 07:23 PM

History

#1 Updated by Szymon Rodzeń over 3 years ago

Yeah, and there's Gorion talking in english and then switching to polish. Also there's english voice-over for "You need to gather your party before traveling forth". This mod fixes all issues, why don't you implement it? http://www.shsforums.net/files/file/1112-polish-language-localization-for-bgee/

#2 Updated by Filip Flechtner over 3 years ago

Note that we cannot simply take all sound files from the Polish vanilla BG1 and add them to BG:EE, because that would make the Polish archive much larger than it needs to be, since it would contain a lot of duplicates of the general sound effects that are not language-specific. Also, BG:EE might have altered some of the original general sound effects. These changes would be overwritten if we copy over the sounds from vanilla BG1.

Therefore I am going through the files individually to isolate all sounds that are actually missing, so we can add those properly. I managed to eliminate 1000 files today, so I am down to 3000 files remaining at the moment. This will take some more time. I will come back to this ticket once I've gone through them all.

Don't worry - I am very familiar with this problem because we have the same situation in the German version as well.

#3 Updated by Piotr "Cahir" Wiankowski over 3 years ago

Filip,
How do you check which files need to be added wnd which not? The task is easy when they sound English, but there are lot of files one have to listen first to hear the difference. Check ghoul or ghast voices for instance, or GANDL files (snoring specifically) - these were recorded in Polish. Let us know if you need help to filter them out.

#4 Updated by Filip Flechtner over 3 years ago

I play every WAV file in NearInfinity. If it does not contain any Polish, and it is anything other than a mechanical sound effect, I play the Polish OGG to hear if it is different. That includes the creature and monster sounds.

I still have 2500 files left, though. So as I said, this will take some time.

#5 Updated by Piotr "Cahir" Wiankowski over 3 years ago

No worries Filip, just wanted to be sure you'll filter all missing .wav's. Take your time.

#6 Updated by Filip Flechtner over 3 years ago

Preparing the ticket for internal report.

I'm saving the original dropbox link here: https://www.dropbox.com/s/69e3pc7qmkvfgji/override.zip?dl=0

#7 Updated by Filip Flechtner over 3 years ago

  • Description updated (diff)
  • Status changed from New to Submitted

I have identified 650 sound files and submitted them with the report. You can check the list in the spoiler at the bottom.

#8 Updated by Piotr "Cahir" Wiankowski over 3 years ago

Great job Filip! I think you've nailed it! Can we expect these voices to be added in the next patch?

#9 Updated by Filip Flechtner over 3 years ago

Thank you, Cahir. I can't really say anything specific about future patches, but you can keep an eye on our Upcoming Patch Preview to see which fixes are being worked on. https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/51466/upcoming-patch-preview

#10 Updated by Anders Svensson over 3 years ago

  • Target version set to Next Update

#11 Updated by Filip Flechtner over 3 years ago

  • Status changed from Submitted to Closed - Fixed
  • % Done changed from 0 to 100

Fixed in v2.2.66.0.

#12 Updated by Jeff "Cerevant" Payne over 3 years ago

  • Target version changed from Next Update to 2.2.66.0

Also available in: Atom PDF